Why Not Bait Our Youth With Hope?

August 10th, 2018

I heard a conservative talk radio host lamenting the opposition to Chicago police filling a car with Nike sneakers in a low income area as bait for young black men. Some stole sneakers, some didn’t, but community activists cried foul. All the while white conservatives said, “if you don’t want to be arrested, don’t steal them.”

And on the surface, that argument flies. But dig just a bit, and you’ll see that it’s not a black or white thing, it’s just a thing. Back in the 70’s, sociologists gave 1000 customers at a bank in an affluent area $20 extra each time they withdrew money from a bank, both from the drive-thru and inside the bank. Fewer than 10% returned the Jacksons. Granted, some may not have realized the mistake, and it is different than reaching into someone else’s car. But when the experiment was repeated in a less affluent area, 50% of  the poorer customers returned the money.

These are cynical times. The immigrant children ripped away from their parents, the Russian scandal, Manafort, Gates, Flynn, and the pay for play Congress all add to our distress. And it weighs upon a weary nation.

Although I’m not sure what these epidemiological studies prove, they do raise a question.  Instead of appealing to man’s less attractive side, why not replace the bait-van with an opportunity van, and fill it with hope? That may sound naive, maybe even pollyannaish, but I believe one can still rise above these dark clouds and shine on a cynical day.

Chip Franklin

Franklin is a 25 year veteran of talk radio, beginning his career in Washington DC during Clinton’s first term. He currently hosts the afternoon show at KGO radio, San Francisco. In addition, Chip is an award-winning filmmaker, comedian, and scribe, garnering seven Edward R Murrow awards, including the National Murrow award for writing. He’s also won The New York Festival honors for his unconventional coverage of The Democratic and Republican conventions, as well as more than 30 AP awards for broadcasting, and numerous appearances on ABC, CBS, FOX, NBC, and CNN. He has appeared at over 500 colleges and universities and more than a hundred Fortune 1000 companies as a speaker, comedian, and media consultant. Marc Fisher, senior editor at the Washington Post says, “Chip adds irony to a medium that rarely trusts its audience to get the joke.” He is however, a mediocre dancer.
See more from

Inside the Beltway